iindaba Homepage | Diocese of PE Homepage
 

Vol 19 No 7
August
2008

iindabaONLINE

The official gazette of the Diocese of Port Elizabeth:
Anglican Church of Southern Africa

Quick Links: Page 1 | Page 2 | Page 3 | Page 4 | Top | Homepage

PAGE 2

 •  MMC - a God ordained moment
 •  Holocaust denial
 •  GAFCON corporately seeking God's will
 •  Letters to the ed


MMC - a God ordained moment
[ Keith Trollip ]

I did what I could not to go to the Mighty Men Conference. There were so many reasons to give it a miss. Praise God there weren't reasons enough! What an incredible weekend - what a privilege it was to be a part of that gathering of 60 000+ men. It was an occasion to be experienced, almost impossible to describe in a few lines. Cars, bakkies, buses, bikers from all over the country kept pouring in. Traffic like that hadn't been witnessed in the area before, and still they came. The world's biggest tent overflowed. The sound of 60 000 men singing praises to an almighty God had to be heard to be believed. How could this have happened other than that an awesome God ordained the event in the first place?

An amazing thing was that with so many people present there was no pushing in queues, no evidence of anyone becoming irritated - just goodwill all around. I heard that there were a couple of drug lords there who were amazed that for the entire duration of the conference they experienced only positive input.

I'm not one who generally likes large gatherings and this, my first MMC, was a record gathering of note! I was in good company as, like myself, there must have been over 40 000 who were on their first MMC. 

Although 30 000 men were expected, double that number arrived. The organization was amazing and Angus and his Shalom team must be congratulated.

What an incredible Holy Spirit experience. I'm sure everyone who attended MMC 08 was touched in some way and would have come away with a different point of view.

Picture: Saturday morning at the MMC - about 07h20 prior to the 09h00 session - and enthusiastic delegates are already waiting in the tent.


Holocaust denial
[ Submitted by Mike Oettle ]

The UK has removed The Holocaust from its school curriculum because it 'offended' the Muslim population which claims it never occurred. Iran, among others, claims the Holocaust did not happen.

The Supreme Commander of the Allied Forces during WWll, General Dwight Eisenhower, said when he found the victims of the death camps - words to this effect: "Get it all on record now - get the films - get the witnesses - because somewhere down the track of history some b*stard will get up and say that this never happened".

He then ordered all possible photographs to be taken, and for the German people from surrounding villages to be ushered through the camps and even made to bury the dead. This is a frightening portent of the fear that is gripping the world and how easily each country is giving in to it. 

This photo was taken in Germany by James Emison Chanslor, an army Master Sergeant who served in World War II from 1942 until 1945.

iindaba publishes this in memory of the six million Jews, 20 million Russians, 10 million Christians and 1,900 Roman Catholic priests who were murdered, massacred, raped, burned, starved and humiliated with the German and Russian peoples looking the other way! Now, more than ever, with Iran, among others, claiming the Holocaust to b e 'a myth,' it is imperative to make sure the world never forgets.

"All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing." - Edmund Burke


GAFCON corporately seeking God's will
[ Gavin Mitchell - Gen Sec Anglican Maintream SA ]

I was a delegate at GAFCON on behalf of Anglican Mainstream Southern Africa. The entire gathering was of such a quantumly different nature to everything I had experienced in the church up to now.

While we had gathered from 27 nations representing between 35 and 40 Million Anglicans (I also learned that in many of the anglican provinces in Africa, membership is counted only of worshippers and not the way we count members here twice a year!), there was an amazing attempt to corporately seek God's will.

As far I could detect there did not seem to be any foregone conclusions when we began. What was evident was the great sadness for our church and the brokenness that we have experienced in the last decade. While the question of homosexuality was the presenting problem for the communion, it was not the focus of our discussions or indeed the statement.  The simplicity of the language of the statement is refreshing, the lack of Anglicanese or even church-speak.

While the challenge to the leadership of the church is real, it seems sadly unavoidable since there is no sign  of the 'instruments of unity' taking any decisive action in the face of the stresses that the actions of the liberal north west has placed on the communion.

In all I can only praise the Lord for the experience and pray that as canon Sugden says, (www.anglican-mainstream.net), perhaps GAFCON can save the communion from its self - destruct mode.

The GAFCON Jerusalem Declaration, and the Abp of Canterbury’s reply, are available from the Bishop's office. See Bishop's letter on page 3.


Letters to the ed

Use of quote by Prof James Barr challenged
While I do not want to stir up further debate on creationist issues, I would like to come to the defence of Prof James Barr. The quote that appeared in iindaba in July has been mischievously used by creationists, as one can see from their many websites devoted to the issue.

The extract referred to the use of the word 'day' to denote longer periods of time, thus enabling people to read current cosmological and evolutionary understanding back into Genesis.

All Prof Barr was saying was that reputable biblical scholars (of whom he was one - he died in 2006) accepted that the writers(s) of Genesis would have understood their words literally. Barr's own position, and presumably also that of the scholars to whom he referred, was that we are not to broaden the meaning of words to fit what we want to say. He intended that we regard the creation accounts as a whole, and interpret them as complete stories, starting first of all from the point of view of the writers.

However, it does not follow that Prof Barr meant that we were to interpret the creation accounts literally, in the sense of interpreting them as a scientific textbook. Barr himself certainly did not do so.

As an illustration of this, we may note that the writer of Ecclesiastes also clearly understood his words literally, that the earth was stationary and that the sun moved! Hopefully, we have learned from the furore over Galileo and Copernicus not to re-open that debate, which we would need to do if we went along with people's misuse of Barr's quote!

Howard Lancaster
All Saints' Church, Kabega.


I read with interest Sue Bennett's account (iindaba, July 2008) of the letter from the great Old Testament scholar James Barr to David Watson. In this letter, Barr seems to be arguing that the writers of Genesis believed their narrative to be literally true.  But his other writings show clearly that he did not believe that himself.

Evangelical Anglican John Stott takes a different view.  He had this to say: "Some Christians today defend the concept of a literal six-day creation, but the text does not demand it, and scientific discovery appears to contradict it.  The biblical text presents itself not as a scientific treatise, but as a highly stylised literary statement." (J Stott, Understanding the Bible, Revised ed., pg 42)

Barr was probably correct that the original writers believed in the literality of the narrative. They would have had no reason to think otherwise. Clearly they also believed that the Earth was at the centre of the universe, otherwise what would it have done until the Sun was created on day four (Gen 1:16-17.)?  But the lasting value of the Creation story lies not so much in the historical narrative, as in the deep spiritual truths which underly it.

When I walked into Faith, I could not walk away from Science.  If the Universe is indeed less than 10 000 years old, if modern animals did not evolve from pre- existing species, and if the entire fossil record was laid down during the Genesis flood, then the scientific community has demonstrated breathtaking incompetence by not noticing this.  And if they got this wrong, what else did they get wrong?  Is it not also possible that HIV does not cause Aids, and that we don't need anti-retrovirals at all? Perhaps it really can be prevented by eating beetroot and taking regular showers!  I think not!

Good Science and good faith empower people.  Why settle for substitutes?

Geoff Booth
Zwartkops River Valley Parish

This correspondence is now closed!



Thank you

St Katharine's, Uitenhage, extend sincere thanks and appreciation to all the clergy who have helped and supported us during this time of interregnum. We have been richly blessed by many from Port Elizabeth, Humansdorp and Uitenhage.

Patty Matthews


Travelling Along the Anglican Way

A new printing with an extra chapter in it has been done of this very popular book by The Revd Fr Roy Snyman tssf. Now also available in Afrikaans. Cost: R50 plus postage and packing (R5) Contact: Tel/fax 041 373 1283 e-mail: fr.roy@telkomsa.net

Quick Links: Page 1 | Page 2 | Page 3 | Page 4 | Top | Homepage

For more information about iindaba,
contact the editor at iindaba@anglicandiocesepe.org.za

iindaba Homepage | Diocese of PE Homepage